Taking Out the Sting

This entry is dedicated to my Project Manager, Carter. There isn’t enough pages to write about all you’ve taught me in such a short period. But this is one of my favorites.

I remember my first punch walk like it was yesterday, and it’s nearly been a decade now. Bright eyed, not sure what to expect. My PM just said to take notes and pictures. I followed the crowd, taking too many notes, not enough of the right ones and as many pictures as my phone would allow. That job had so much blue tape, and by the look on my PM’s face, that wasn’t a good sign. But I saw it. I saw what we were looking for. I saw how the owner wanted this brand new space to be absolutely perfect: clean, no scratches anywhere, no paint missing, the fridge to open on the correct side… And while those seemingly small details might annoy someone who’s worked tireless hours to meet the project deadline, I loved to see the satisfaction on the owners face when we handed them the finished product.

Preparation for a punch walk is a lot like the dance in its own way. It is the worst plan to walk into a punch list 15 minutes before go time. I learned that lesson the hard way. After so many of these walks, project managers tend to take one of two approaches. The first, and also the worst, is to show up right before the punch, take zero notes, wait for the list to come from the AOR and then scramble to sort it out after. The second, my favorite, and seemingly the most effective, is to get there a few hours before, make your own list and take out the sting before the owner and architect have a chance to call you out.

Walking this job I didn’t start and barely got to see finish has got me reminiscing on one of my favorite parts about the PE role. I’m walking the entire building, scanning the rooms, walls and surfaces for obvious errors and at the same time recalling every single item I ever received on punch lists before this one. Some items are too obvious, it’s almost frustrating to walk around with your superintendent and question how they could accept this as finished work: the scratched drywall, the poor tile schluter installation, and the missing rubber base in half of a room. And then there are the not so obvious items, like the horizontal mullions on the storefront being crooked or spaced out too far. Or even the caulk lines that could be better. And the worst of all is when you realize something is just completely missing as you look up at the ceiling to see a perfect core in the tile where the security camera should be. There is always something to add to the list. But what will be the item you forgot to remember? This is where preparation comes in for me. I have to know my plans, I have to know what’s missing. Because if it’s called out and I don’t know it’s missing, well maybe they’d forgive the 20-year veteran, but they are expecting me to be sharp.

One of my favorite PMs taught me about taking out the sting. I watched him give the download to our boss ahead of that walk, address the obvious and the less obvious and without fail, the boss lowered his shoulders, took a breath, and the rest was smooth sailing. “Taking out the sting” he called it. Don’t wait for the owner to bring up the elephant in the room or find the mouse in the corner. Address it head-on with your plan of remediation. We won the client over that day and became irreplaceable to not only our boss, but the program we were on.

And the perfect punch walk? The zero-punch list? Well that day might come eventually. But for now, every walk is its own record of what experience hasn’t taught you yet.

Published by All The Grey Area

A blog about a woman, in Construction.

Leave a Reply